More than 27,000 abandoned oil and gas wells lurk in the hard
rock beneath the Gulf of Mexico, an environmental minefield that
has been ignored for decades. No one - not industry, not government
- is checking to see if they are leaking, an Associated Press
investigation shows.
The oldest of these wells were abandoned in the late 1940s,
raising the prospect that many deteriorating sealing jobs are
already failing.
The AP investigation uncovered particular concern with 3,500 of
the neglected wells - those characterized in federal government
records as "temporarily abandoned."
Regulations for temporarily abandoned wells require oil
companies to present plans to reuse or permanently plug such wells
within a year, but the AP found that the rule is routinely
circumvented, and that more than 1,000 wells have lingered in that
unfinished condition for more than a decade. About three-quarters
of temporarily abandoned wells have been left in that status for
more than a year, and many since the 1950s and 1960s - eveb though
sealing procedures for temporary abandonment are not as stringent
as those for permanent closures.
As a forceful reminder of the potential harm, the well beneath
BP's Deepwater Horizon rig was being sealed with cement for
temporary abandonment when it blew April 20, leading to one of the
worst environmental disasters in the nation's history. BP alone has
abandoned about 600 wells in the Gulf, according to government
data.
There's ample reason for worry about all permanently and
temporarily abandoned wells - history shows that at least on land,
they often leak. Wells are sealed underwater much as they are on
land. And wells on land and in water face similar risk of failure.
Plus, records reviewed by the AP show that some offshore wells have
failed.
Experts say such wells can repressurize, much like a dormant
volcano can awaken. And years of exposure to sea water and
underground pressure can cause cementing and piping to corrode and
weaken.
"You can have changing geological conditions where a well could
be repressurized," said Andy Radford, a petroleum engineer for the
American Petroleum Institute trade group.
Whether a well is permanently or temporarily abandoned,
improperly applied or aging cement can crack or shrink, independent
petroleum engineers say. "It ages, just like it does on buildings
and highways," said Roger Anderson, a Columbia University
petroleum geophysicist who has conducted research on commercial
wells.
Despite the likelihood of leaks large and small, though,
abandoned wells are typically not inspected by industry or
government.
Oil company representatives insist that the seal on a correctly
plugged offshore well will last virtually forever.
"It's in everybody's interest to do it right," said Bill
Mintz, a spokesman for Apache Corp., which has at least 2,100
abandoned wells in the Gulf, according to government data.
Officials at the U.S. Interior Department, which oversees the
agency that regulates federal leases in the Gulf and elsewhere, did
not answer repeated questions regarding why there are no
inspections of abandoned wells.
State officials estimate that tens of thousands are badly
sealed, either because they predate strict regulation or because
the operating companies violated rules. Texas alone has plugged
more than 21,000 abandoned wells to control pollution, according to
the state comptroller's office.
Offshore, but in state waters, California has resealed scores of
its abandoned wells since the 1980s.
In deeper federal waters, though - despite the similarities in
how such wells are constructed and how sealing procedures can fail
- the official policy is out-of-sight, out-of-mind.
The U.S. Minerals Management Service - the regulatory agency
recently renamed the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management, Regulation
and Enforcement - relies on rules that have few real teeth. Once an
oil company says it will permanently abandon a well, it has one
year to complete the job. MMS mandates that work plans be submitted
and a report filed afterward.
Unlike California regulators, MMS doesn't typically inspect the
job, instead relying on the paperwork.
The fact there are so many wells that have been classified for
decades as temporarily abandoned suggests that paperwork can be
shuffled at MMS without any real change beneath the water.
With its weak system of enforcement, MMS imposed fines in a
relative handful of cases: just $440,000 on seven companies from
2003-2007 for improper plug-and-abandonment work.
Companies permanently abandon wells when they are no longer
useful. Afterward, no one looks methodically for leaks, which can't
easily be detected from the surface anyway. And no one in
government or industry goes underwater to inspect, either.
Government regulators and industry officials say abandoned
offshore wells are presumed to be properly plugged and are expected
to last indefinitely without leaking. Only when pressed do these
officials acknowledge the possibility of leaks.
Despite warnings of leaks, government and industry officials
have never bothered to assess the extent of the problem, according
to an extensive AP review of records and regulations.
That means no one really knows how many abandoned wells are
leaking - and how badly.
The AP documented an extensive history of warnings about
environmental dangers related to abandoned wells:
- The General Accountability Office, which investigates for
Congress, warned as early as 1994 that leaks from offshore
abandoned wells could cause an "environmental disaster," killing
fish, shellfish, mammals and plants. In a lengthy report, GAO
pressed for inspections of abandonment jobs, but nothing came of
the recommendation.
- A 2006 Environmental Protection Agency report took notice of
the overall issue regarding wells on land: "Historically, well
abandonment and plugging have generally not been properly planned,
designed and executed." State officials say many leaks come from
wells abandoned in recent decades, when rules supposedly dictated
plugging procedures. And repairs are so routine that terms have
been coined to describe the work: "replugging" or the
"re-abandonment."
- A GAO report in 1989 provided a foreboding prognosis about the
health of the country's inland oil and gas wells. The watchdog
agency quoted EPA data estimating that up to 17 percent of the
nation's wells on land had been improperly plugged. If that
percentage applies to offshore wells, there could be 4,600 badly
plugged wells in the Gulf of Mexico alone.
- According to a 2001 study commissioned by MMS, agency
officials were "concerned that some abandoned oil wells in the
Gulf may be leaking crude oil." But nothing came of that warning
either.
The study targeted a well 20 miles off Louisiana that had been
reported leaking five years after it was plugged and abandoned. The
researchers tried unsuccessfully to use satellite radar images to
locate the leak.
But John Amos, the geologist who wrote the study, told AP that
MMS withheld critical information that could have helped verify if
he had pinpointed the problem. "I kind of suspected that this was
a project almost designed to fail," Amos said. He said the agency
refused to tell him "how big and widespread a problem" they were
dealing with in the Gulf.
Amos is now director of SkyTruth, a nonprofit group that uses
satellite imagery to detect environmental problems. He still
believes that technology could work on abandoned wells.
MMS, though, hasn't followed up on the work. And Interior
Department spokeswoman Kendra Barkoff said agency inspectors would
be present for permanent plugging jobs "only when something
unusual is expected." She also said inspectors would check later
"only if there's a noted leak." But she did not respond to
requests for examples.
Companies may be tempted to skimp on sealing jobs, which are
expensive and slow offshore. It would cost the industry at least $3
billion to permanently plug the 10,500 now-active wells and the
3,500 temporarily abandoned ones in the Gulf, according to an AP
analysis of MMS data.
The AP analysis indicates that more than half of the 50,000
wells ever drilled on federal leases beneath the Gulf have now been
abandoned. Some 23,500 are permanently sealed. Another 12,500 wells
are plugged on one branch while being allowed to remain active in a
different branch.
Government records do not indicate how many temporarily
abandoned wells have been returned to service over the years.
Federal rules require only an annual review of plans to reuse or
permanently seal the 3,500 temporarily abandoned wells, but
companies are using this provision to keep the wells in limbo
indefinitely.
Petroleum engineers say abandoned offshore wells can fail from
faulty work, age and drilling-induced or natural changes below the
seabed. Maurice Dusseault, a geologist at the University of
Waterloo in Ontario, Canada, says U


