|Published:||Jun 25, 2012 9:29 PM EDT|
|Updated:||Jun 25, 2012 9:29 PM EDT|
TALLAHASSEE, Fla. (AP) - Gov. Rick Scott could get a chance to overhaul the Florida Supreme Court.
A conservative legal group on Monday filed a lawsuit that aims to block three Florida Supreme Court justices from getting new six-year terms on the court.
Voters this fall are supposed to decide whether to keep Justices Fred Lewis, Barbara Pariente and Peggy Quince on the bench.
But the Southeastern Legal Foundation, which filed suit on behalf of two Florida residents, contends that three justices did not property fill out their election-related paperwork and did not follow state law. The group is asking a Leon County circuit judge to order state election officials to remove their names from the November ballot.
"As has been the case with other candidates for high office in Florida and elsewhere, the laws and rules that govern elections and public disclosures are designed to provide public accountability and sometimes result in disqualification from the ballot," said Shannon Goessling, executive director of the foundation. "For those in the legal profession in public office, particularly judges, there is an additional, heightened duty to follow the rules to the fullest extent because we ask judges to determine what the law is."
In Florida, appeals judges and supreme court justices are appointed by the governor. But instead of running for re-election, they are subject to an up-or-down merit retention vote.
The three justices nearly missed the deadline to qualify for the ballot in April. The seven-member court abruptly put a hearing on hold for more than an hour to allow the justices to finish their paperwork and turn it in to state elections officials with just minutes to spare.
The justices wound up using court employees to notarize the paperwork. A state law prohibits candidates for office from using state employees to help their campaign during working hours, although it is unclear if that law applies to judges. A violation of the law is a misdemeanor.
Although attorneys for the justices contend that they did nothing wrong, the state opened a criminal investigation earlier this month after a state legislator complained.
There was no immediate comment Monday from representatives of the justices about the lawsuit.
Chris Cate, a spokesman for Secretary of State Kent Detzner, said that the department has not yet seen the lawsuit. But he pointed out that state election officials have a "ministerial" role in processing election-related paperwork.
The three justices named in the lawsuit have drawn the ire of Republicans, including Scott. Two of the justices were appointed by the late Democratic Gov. Lawton Chiles; Quince was jointly appointed by Chiles and then-incoming-Gov. Jeb Bush.
In 2010, the state Supreme Court removed from the ballot three constitutional amendments pushed by the GOP-controlled Legislature including a "health care freedom" amendment that would have made it illegal in Florida to have a health insurance mandate. Legislators reworked the amendment in 2011 and placed it on this year's ballot.
Scott did not comment directly on the lawsuit Monday. But he said he said the justices should be required to follow the law.
"It's the Supreme Court, you think they would comply with the law," Scott said.
The Southeastern Legal Foundation is the same group that pushed to have President Bill Clinton give up his law license.
Associated Press writer Brent Kallestad contributed to this report.
Follow Gary Fineout on Twitter: http://twitter.com/fineout
(Copyright 2012 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.)